| Newsletter
April 2006 Article |
|
|
| Outdoor
Burning Rule Changes and VFDs |
|
| Disclaimer:
This article does not constitute legal advice. For
your jurisdiction's specific situation you need to
consult your City or County Attorney, or, if you are
a non-government, your attorney. The purposes of this
article are to lay out some general guidelines
for understanding and using Texas Health &
Safety Code Chapters 341, 343 and 365, Texas Water
Code Chapter 7, the Texas Outdoor Burning rule and
other Texas statutes and rules to fight illegal
dumping and burning in your jurisdiction, and to
facilitate discussion of these subjects within the
enforcement community. |
|
|
| Coming changes
in the Texas Outdoor Burning rule fall into two areas: (1)
changes that will allow on-site burning of leaves, grass
and other plant growth waste by the property owners or
designees just about anywhere in Texas (except in NAAQS
non-attainment counties); and, (2) changes that will allow
consolidated plant growth waste burn sites to be operated
outside of cities in counties having a population under
50,000 (200 of our 254 counties). These consolidated burns
can only be conducted if firefighters are present.
However, volunteer firefighters are not eligible to serve
as site monitors, which is likely to create a lot of
confusion across Texas.
The current Texas Outdoor Burning rule being what it
is, there has been a lot of confusion over just what or
who can OK an outdoor fire. The rule is clear if you work
your way through it carefully. There are two primary
sources of authorizations to burn: (1) the Outdoor Burning
rule itself, written through an open process; and, (2)
certain people designated within the rule who can
authorize various types of outdoor fires not specifically
authorized within the rule itself. For example, the language of the
rule authorizes fires for recreation, ceremony, cooking
and warmth, crop residue clearing, and a number of other
common purposes, and the TCEQ commissioner can authorize
disposal fires under unique circumstances not covered by
the rule, such as the need to dispose of a huge amount of
wood debris following a bad storm. Another example is that
local air pollution
control agencies, where they exist, can authorize outdoor
burning for training fire-fighting personnel. Where there
are no such agencies, regional TCEQ offices can issue such
authorization. Veterinarians can authorize burning
diseased animal carcasses if they think that the best
thing to do, and so on. All of these authorizing persons and agencies
as well as various pre-authorized situations where burning
is allowed are covered in the Texas Outdoor Burning rule.
Commissioners courts through burn bans and county
judges through declarations of emergencies can further
limit burning under emergency conditions. However, neither
judge nor commissioner can authorize burning; the lifting
of a burn ban simply causes the situation to revert to the
provisions of the Texas Outdoor Burning rule.
Trash burning is not authorized where waste disposal
services are available. This would normally include all
cities in Texas and counties over 30,000 (THSC Section 363.113
requires counties to assure that solid waste services are
available to all residents when they reach that population
mark). At the present moment, grass, leaves, branches and
other plant growth waste are also included in the
definition of "domestic waste" that cannot
normally be burned. All this will change in June, however,
should the TCEQ commissioners give final approval to the
impending modifications to the rule. Leaves, grass, limbs
and other plant growth waste will be treated differently
and will become OK to burn in most of Texas.
It is unlikely that cities will be able to restrict
burning through local municipal ordinances. Local
communities can have ordinances regulating burning, but
according to the Texas Health & Safety Code Section
382.113(b), that part of the Texas Clean Air Act that
addresses the power of municipalities to further regulate
outdoor burning: "An
ordinance enacted by a municipality must be consistent
with this chapter and the commission's rules and orders
and may not make unlawful a condition or act approved or
authorized under this chapter or the commission's rules or
orders." The state sets the limits on
burning, not local municipalities.
Recent changes by the State Legislature and the
impending TCEQ rule change will give the right to
residents to burn plant growth waste on the property where
is grows in most circumstances. Municipalities and fire
departments may face a period of getting use to this new
situation. Only plant growth waste will be eligible for
burning; however, some citizens will no doubt also take
the opportunity to burn the odd sack of trash. Or tire or
two.
But it is the second part of the new law and rule that
we think may be most confusing to fire-fighters in the
state: the changes that allow consolidated rural plant
growth waste burn sites in 200 of our 254 counties. The
elements of this new law bear reading:
Texas
Health & Safety Code Chapter 382: Clean Air Act
§ 382.018. Outdoor Burning of Waste and Combustible
Material. |
| (a)
Subject to Section 352.082, and except as provided
by Subsections (b) and (d), the commission by rule
may control and prohibit the outdoor burning of
waste and combustible material and may include
requirements concerning the particular method to be
used to control or abate the emission of air
contaminants resulting from that burning.
|
| (d)
The commission may not control or prohibit outdoor
burning of waste consisting of trees, brush, grass,
leaves, branch trimmings, or other plant growth if:
|
| |
(1)
the person burning the waste is doing so at a site:
|
| |
|
(A)
designated for consolidated burning of waste
generated from specific residential properties;
|
| |
|
(B)
located in a county with a population of less than
50,000;
|
| |
|
(C)
located outside of a municipality; and
|
| |
|
(D)
supervised at the time of the burning by an employee
of a fire department who is part of the fire
protection personnel, as defined by Section 419.021,
Government Code, of the department and is acting in
the scope of the person's employment; and
|
| |
(2)
the waste was generated from a property for which
the site is designated.
|
| (e)
A fire department employee who will supervise a
burning under Subsection (d)(1)(D) shall notify the
commission of each burning supervised by the
employee, and the commission shall provide the
employee with information on practical alternatives
to burning.
|
The new Texas Outdoor Burning rule modifications
enact this statute with even greater detail and should
be closely consulted by anyone wanting to run such a
site, supervise a burn or enforce illegal dumping and
burning laws in the
jurisdiction.
The new role anticipated for fire-fighters is shown
above. Consolidated burning can only be done
legally if the process is supervised by a member of the
"fire protection personnel" of a fire
department, acting in the scope of his or her
employment, all as defined by Section 419.021 of the
Government Code.
Texas
Government Code Chapter 419. Texas Commission on
Fire Protection
§ 419.021. Definitions. |
| In
this subchapter:
|
| (3)
"Fire protection personnel" means:
|
| |
(A)
permanent, full-time law enforcement officers
designated as fire and arson investigators by an
appropriate local authority;
|
| |
(B)
aircraft rescue and fire protection personnel; or
|
| |
(C)
permanent, full-time fire department employees who
are not secretaries, stenographers, clerks, budget
analysts, or similar support staff persons or other
administrative employees and who are assigned duties
in one or more of the following categories:
|
| |
|
(i) fire
suppression;
|
| |
|
(ii)
fire inspection;
|
| |
|
(iii)
fire and arson investigation;
|
| |
|
(iv)
marine fire fighting;
|
| |
|
(v)
aircraft rescue and fire fighting;
|
| |
|
(vi)
fire training;
|
| |
|
(vii)
fire education;
|
| |
|
(viii)
fire administration; and
|
| |
|
(ix) any
other position necessarily or customarily related to
fire prevention or suppression.
|
Notice that this definition does not include the
three-fourths of fire-fighters in the state who serve as
volunteers rather than as permanent, full-time fire
department employees. These volunteers, who do the bulk of
fire fighting in exactly those 200 smallest counties in
the state, are not eligible to perform supervisory duty at
consolidated burn sites under the new law.
However, just as fire-fighters are regularly and
inappropriately requested throughout Texas to give
permission for rural disposal fires, they will be
inappropriately requested in the future by the public to perform
supervisory duties at consolidated burn sites. In neither
case are they authorized by law to act. In both cases they
could face personal liability if the fire gets out of
control and destroys someone’s property. If the
supervision of a consolidated burn site by a volunteer
fire-fighter is a matter of that VFD's policy, the entire
department may well be financially liable for any mishaps.
The new rule allowing consolidated rural burn sites
requires the presence of full-time employees of fire
departments. Members of VFDs should avoid getting put in
the position of supervising these sites. VFD Chiefs and
Board members should make sure that their VFD does not
participate in supervising these sites. If approached by a
site owner to provide such services, volunteer
fire-fighters should refer the inquiry to a fire
department having full-time employees. Virtually all of
these departments are located inside cities. Probably few of these
will be disposed to use municipally paid fire-fighters and
equipment out in rural areas in non-emergency situations,
such as monitoring disposal fires at consolidated
sites.
|
|